Severity levels

The company sets the levels. You see them before you start.

Every company on Exploity publishes its own table, P1 to P5, with what each level means to it and what it pays. A researcher sees that table on the offer, and it is fixed for the job once they accept.

The five levels

Our starting table.

A company can publish this as it is, or rewrite every line in its own words. The amounts are always the company's own.

LevelNameWhat usually belongs here
P1CriticalSomeone outside the company can take over accounts or systems, or read or change sensitive data for many customers, without help from a victim.
P2HighSerious harm that needs a condition to be met first: a signed-in account, a specific customer, or a step the victim must take.
P3MediumLimited harm: data or actions of little sensitivity, or an attack that is hard to carry out in practice.
P4LowA weakness with little direct harm on its own, worth fixing as good practice.
P5InformationalAn observation with no security harm shown. Recorded with thanks; no bounty.

How a level is decided

Four steps, and nobody is left guessing.

  1. Published first

    The company's table is on the offer, next to the scope. No table, no offer.

  2. Fixed on acceptance

    A company can change its table at any time, but only for future jobs. Yours keeps the table you accepted.

  3. The researcher proposes

    After sending the report to the company, the researcher picks the kind of issue and the level they believe it is.

  4. The company settles it

    It confirms the level or picks another. A different level needs a reason, chosen from a short list.

What Exploity does

We check the bounty against the table, not the bug.

We never receive the report, so we do not rate findings. Our part is simple: the bounty a company sends for approval has to match its own table for the level it chose. It may pay more. It may not pay less than the lowest amount it published.

  • A record, not a ranking. Once a company has decided five reports, researchers see how often it kept or raised the proposed level, and how long it usually takes.
  • Labels only. We keep the kind of issue and the level. We never keep what the finding is or where it is.
  • $50 from us. Added to valid findings with a bounty of $250 or more, at any level.

For companies

Two minutes, then reuse it.

Enter your bounty range and we fill the whole table for you. Change any line if you want to. Save a table under a name, such as "Web apps" or "Payments", and use it again whenever you publish a scope.

You also choose which kinds of issue you accept, from one short list.

Stopping a test

You can stop at any moment.

If you are fixing something, handling an incident, or sent a request by mistake, stop the test from the app. The researcher is told at once to stop testing, and it never counts against them.

A test can be stopped until the report is in. After that, you decide on the report as usual.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Who has the final say on the level?

The company. It knows its own systems and wrote the table. What it cannot do is change the table after a researcher has accepted, or pay less than the table says for the level it chose.

What if a researcher disagrees with the level?

They can talk to the company in the job's conversation, and either side can ask our team to step in. We do not overrule the company's level, but the company's record of kept and changed levels is visible to every researcher it is offered to.

Does Exploity use CVSS or another scoring system?

No. A company is free to base its own table on any system it likes. Researchers only need to read the table on the offer.

Can a company accept only some kinds of issue?

Yes. It picks the kinds it accepts from one short list. "Something else" is always allowed, so a researcher is never forced to mislabel a finding.

What happens to a P5?

It is recorded as informational. It pays no bounty and does not count against the researcher.

Clear levels before the work starts.